To choose between a rattan lamp and a fabric one, look at the weave and openings before the material label. An open weave leaves parts of the source visible and may cast patterned shadows; a translucent fabric shade may create a more continuous luminous surface. The result depends on the complete construction.
Also think about what you want to highlight: the texture of the lamp when it is off, a pattern on the wall or a subtle lighting presence. These are different criteria. A styled photograph is not enough to tell you how much light will reach your table or how the lamp will look from the sofa.
These photographs show both models switched off, so you can compare their weave and finish. To assess the light and shadows, look for images of the model switched on with the bulb used clearly identified.
In an open shade, the fibres block some of the light while the gaps let some through. Look at the spacing between strips, their thickness and whether there is an inner diffuser. Two rattan shades can produce different effects even if they share the same material and colour.
The IKEA KAPPELAND model specifically describes its open weave as contributing to the decorative light. This is a design example, not a rule for every weave. A denser or lined shade may conceal much more of the source.
If you like patterns on the wall, ask for photographs of the model switched on and details of the bulb used. Do not assume that the pattern will have the same sharpness or size in your home: the source, distances and surfaces receiving the light will differ.
A fabric shade may filter light through its sides, direct it mainly through its openings or combine both effects. Thickness, lining, colour and layers all matter. A light-coloured finish does not guarantee that the whole side is translucent.
For reference, IKEA describes the RINGSTA fabric shade as diffusing light. For another product, check its own construction. An opaque shade or one with a different lining should not automatically be given the same description.
Look at seams, folds and the internal frame in photographs with the light on: they may form part of the visible appearance. If you want a particularly uniform surface, ask for a detailed photograph instead of inferring it from the fabric's colour.
| What to check | Rattan | Fabric |
|---|---|---|
| Light through the sides | Depends on gaps and any diffusers. | Depends on the fabric, layers and lining. |
| Visible light source | May be visible between the fibres. | May be visible through openings or show through the fabric. |
| Shadows | The weave may create patterns. | A diffusing surface may soften their appearance. |
| Maintenance | Check access between fibres without distorting them. | Check the permitted cleaning method for the fabric and its seams. |
The ERCO guide to diffuse and directed light explains how light distribution and the luminous surface affect the appearance of shadows. When choosing a lamp for your home, this is a reason to check the actual bulb-and-shade combination, without expecting a precise effect from the material alone.
Imagine a plain wall beside a seat where you spend time. If you want shadow patterns to be part of the decor, examine an open shade and check that the source is comfortable to view from the seat. If you prefer the wall to draw less attention, consider a diffusing shade and check its openings.
Also look at the lamp switched off in daylight. You may prefer the rattan weave during the day and an understated fabric at night, or the reverse. Note which of those moments matters more to your choice before comparing models.
The 20024 rattan wall light has a woven shade on a metal frame and mounts on the wall. It requires an E14 bulb up to 15 W, not included. Its openings contribute to the decorative effect on the wall.
The 20094 fabric pendant light uses three overlapping shades and a single E27 bulb up to 20 W, not included. It mounts on the ceiling and has an opening at the bottom. Three shades do not mean three light sources.
These products illustrate materials and construction types; they are not equivalent substitutes. A wall light close to a wall and a pendant occupy different positions and distribute light from different places. Both examples are for dry indoor use. Check the bulb's actual electrical wattage and the model's limit, as well as the available space.
An example of an open rattan shade positioned beside a wall.
Requires an E14 bulb up to 15 W, not included. For dry indoor use; do not force the weave to access the lampholder.
View details and optionsAn example of three overlapping fabric shades in a pendant fitting.
Uses an E27 bulb up to 20 W, not included. Check the size and suspension, and clean the shade using a dry method.
View details and optionsAccess for dusting matters as much as the finish. Check whether you can reach the shade without pulling the cable or putting weight on the weave or fabric. Do not assume a shade can be removed: follow only the documented procedure.
Disconnect the power supply and let the bulb cool before carrying out any work. Shade 20094 is specified for cleaning using a dry method. For other models, consult their instructions before applying products or moisture; a material resembling furniture or clothing does not mean it can receive the same treatment.
Do not force the fibres apart to insert cleaning tools or improvise washing, steam cleaning or spraying on the fitting. If a stain does not come out with the permitted method, consult the supplier.
Only if the manufacturer expressly permits it. Do not assume it is washable because it is fabric.
The material name does not establish that conclusion. Verifiable product information would be needed.
See how to assess colour rendering on fabrics and what is involved in choosing a replaceable bulb. You will find more content in the lighting guides index.
